Sciencepulse

Before the Big Bang: Can Science Ever Know What Came First?

Science·November 1, 2026

A new crossover episode pairs two science podcasts. Rachel Feltman, host of Scientific American's Science Quickly, appears on Vox's Unexplainable to talk with host Noam Hassenfeld about a special issue of Scientific American devoted to questions that may never get clean answers.

The conversation covers a lot of ground. One topic is how some common medications help patients even though scientists do not fully understand the mechanisms behind them. Another is whether there is a ceiling on what humans can ever know. The discussion then heads to the edge of cosmology, where the two hosts weigh competing ideas about what might have come before the big bang.

That last question is a good test case for the limits of knowledge. The big bang model describes how the observable universe expanded from a hot, dense early state, but its equations break down as you approach the very earliest moment. Proposals about an earlier phase, such as a universe that bounced out of a previous contraction, are interesting physics, yet current observations have a hard time confirming or ruling them out. The gap is not only a matter of waiting for better telescopes. Some of the evidence may simply be out of reach.

The episode's framing suggests that some of these puzzles could stay open for good. For listeners who want more, the show points to two Scientific American pieces: "Finding meaning in the impossible" and "The questions science may never answer."