Sciencepulse

Dark Oxygen: A Deep-Sea Claim Still Divides Scientists

Science·October 26, 2026

Dark Oxygen: A Deep-Sea Claim Still Divides Scientists

In July 2024, a paper in the journal Nature Geoscience reported something that should not happen. Oxygen appeared to be produced on the Pacific seafloor, roughly 4,000 metres down, where no sunlight reaches. The team, led by Andrew Sweetman of the Scottish Association for Marine Science, pointed to polymetallic nodules, lumpy deposits rich in manganese, nickel and cobalt that carpet parts of the abyssal plain, as the possible source.

The reason the claim jolted researchers is that oxygen is usually tied to photosynthesis. Plants and microbes that capture light split water and release it, and that process has long been the textbook explanation for how the air and the oceans get their oxygen. A suggestion that metal lumps on the dark seabed could generate it by some other route would, if confirmed, force a rethink of a basic assumption about how life on Earth is supported.

Other scientists were quick to push back. Critics questioned whether the sensors used at those depths could be trusted, whether instrument drift or contamination could explain the readings, and whether the proposed chemistry added up. The disagreement played out in public as well as in journals, and it grew sharper over time. Headlines ran with the most dramatic version of the story, while the technical arguments were harder to follow from the outside.

BBC science correspondent Victoria Gill returns to the episode in Dark Breath, broadcast on Radio 4. The programme frames it as a controversy unfolding in close to real time, and as one that became personal as well as scientific. It also connects the debate to a wider political question: the same stretch of seabed holds nodules that companies want to mine. Whether the deep ocean is a passive store of metals or an active part of Earth's chemistry matters to the arguments over whether mining should go ahead.

The programme asks what the story reveals about how science actually works, with its slow testing, its rival teams and its pressure from public attention. It also asks the simplest question of all: a year and a half after the paper, are we any closer to knowing whether dark oxygen is real?

Reporting based on an external source.