Sciencepulse

Jaws Got the Hunter Right and the Hierarchy Wrong: Orcas Are Pushing Great Whites Off Their Turf

Science·November 19, 2026

Jaws Got the Hunter Right and the Hierarchy Wrong: Orcas Are Pushing Great Whites Off Their Turf

Few animals carry as much cultural baggage as the great white shark. Since Steven Spielberg's Jaws turned a toothy fish into a summer nightmare in 1975, the species has been cast as a relentless man-eater, a creature built for one purpose. The reality is more interesting. Great whites are formidable hunters, and adults can reach several meters in length, but they are not the ocean's apex predator. That title belongs to the orca, and a growing body of field research suggests that killer whales are quietly rewriting the great white's daily routine.

The shark's hunting toolkit is impressive in its own right. Great whites often operate in cold, murky water where sight is limited, so they lean on other senses. Clusters of electroreceptors around the snout, known as the ampullae of Lorenzini, pick up the faint electrical fields that every living animal produces, including the small muscle contractions of a fish hidden in the sand. A lateral line running along the body registers pressure changes and vibrations in the water. Seals are a favored meal in many regions, and the classic hunt is built on ambush. A shark will approach from deep water, use the depths as cover, and then burst upward through the surface with enough force to clear it entirely. The strike is short, violent and relies heavily on surprise.

Surprise, however, only works when a predator is not itself being hunted. That is where the story shifts. Dr Alison Towner, a postdoctoral researcher at Rhodes University in South Africa who holds a PhD in white shark ecology, has been studying how great whites are being displaced by orcas along the South African coast. Her work sits at the intersection of behavior and ecology: the question is not only whether orcas attack sharks, but how the arrival of a hunter that can overpower a great white changes where the shark goes, when it feeds and how long it stays in a given area.

Orcas are among the most capable hunters in the sea. They hunt cooperatively, communicate across long distances and adjust their tactics to the prey in front of them. Observers in South Africa have recorded orcas going after great whites, and in some cases the attacks have targeted the shark's liver, an organ rich in oil. For a great white, losing a feeding ground to a pod of killer whales is not a minor inconvenience. Each relocation means time, energy and a risk of running into a less productive hunting area, and the effects can ripple outward into the wider food web, including the seal populations that great whites usually help keep in check.

Understanding those ripples requires more than watching individual encounters. Professor Gavin Naylor, director of the Florida Program for Shark Research, specializes in evolutionary and population genetics, and his field is one of the tools scientists use to answer bigger questions. Genetic data can show whether shark populations are isolated or mixing, how many distinct groups exist in a region and how well a population can absorb pressure. If a species is being pushed out of familiar waters, those genetic answers help determine whether the animals are simply relocating or whether the displacement is splitting populations in ways that could be harder to reverse.

It is also worth revisiting the teeth that made the great white famous. Sharks do not keep the same set for life. They shed and replace teeth continuously, with new ones moving forward in rows, so a shark's mouth works more like a conveyor belt than a fixed set of tools. The serrated edges are excellent for gripping and cutting prey, but they are only part of the picture. The shark's senses, its patience and its choice of hunting ground matter just as much.

The great white's real vulnerability is not the one Hollywood sold audiences. It is the slow, practical problem of sharing the ocean with a predator that can outthink and outmuscle it. As researchers continue to track how orcas reshape the shark's habits, the picture that emerges is less a story of a monster at the top of the food chain and more one of an animal adapting, sometimes successfully, to a sea where the real apex predator is not the one on the movie poster.

Reporting based on an external source.