Lifesaving Tools Built Around Men Are Failing Women
Health Tech·October 23, 2026
Medical devices are supposed to work the same way for every patient. A CPR mannequin, a hip implant or a surgical instrument is judged on whether it does its job, and the people who use it rarely think about who it was designed for. A new investigation, presented by Ella Hubber and produced with journalist Candice Bailey, argues that for many devices the answer has long been the same: a default male body.
The core problem is the "one-size-fits-all" approach. Engineers and clinicians often start from average male measurements, such as body size, weight, chest dimensions or hand size, and treat everything else as a variation to handle later, if at all. Women differ in height, bone structure, body composition and hormone levels, and those differences can change how a device fits, how it moves and how the body responds to it.
Research gaps make the problem harder to see. If clinical studies and testing include far fewer women, a device can look successful on paper while performing worse for the people it was not tested on. The programme points to higher complication rates in women as one result. Because those harms are often spread across individual cases rather than collected in one place, they can go unnoticed for years.
The issue also reaches emergency care. Training mannequins and the guidance built around them have historically reflected male proportions, which can shape how bystanders learn to compress a chest. Research has also suggested that women are less likely than men to receive bystander CPR in public cardiac arrests, so a tool that shapes rescuers' instincts carries real weight.
Even inside the operating theatre, equipment and procedures can be set up with a male patient in mind, from the sizing of instruments to how a patient is positioned on the table. Small mismatches may seem minor, but they can add up across a surgery.
The investigation does not stop at diagnosis. It asks what change could look like, including broader recruitment in trials, routine reporting of results broken down by sex, and design processes that test devices on a wider range of bodies before they reach patients. As awareness grows, the question is whether the tools used in healthcare can finally serve every body, not just the one they were first built for.
Reporting based on an external source.