Sciencepulse

Michael Pollan Asks Why Consciousness Still Resists Definition

Neuroscience·November 16, 2026

Consciousness is the most familiar thing any of us will ever experience, yet science has struggled for decades to say exactly what it is. In a new episode of Scientific American's Science Quickly podcast, journalist Michael Pollan talks with host Bri Kane about why that gap persists. The conversation treats the difficulty of definition as the central obstacle, since researchers and philosophers still disagree about what counts as awareness and how it could be measured.

Pollan approaches the subject from several directions. The episode considers what brain science can tell us about the activity linked to awareness, and what experiments with artificial intelligence might show about systems that behave intelligently without any clear sign of inner experience. It also brings in psychedelics, which researchers have been studying for how they change perception and the sense of self. The episode frames these altered states as a possible window into how ordinary awareness is put together, though the idea is offered as a question to explore rather than a settled answer.

The discussion is tied to Pollan's new book, A World Appears: A Journey into Consciousness, published by Penguin in 2026. Scientific American also points listeners to two companion reads: a guide to 29 competing theories of consciousness, and an explainer on why consciousness is often described as the hardest problem in science.

For listeners, the main takeaway is that the question remains wide open. Theories of consciousness multiply faster than experiments can settle them, and AI makes the problem more pressing, because it forces people to decide what evidence would ever count as a sign that a machine is aware. The episode is a useful starting point for anyone who wants an overview of the terrain before turning to the literature.