New York Says T-Mobile's 50GB Cap on Low-Income Internet Plan Is Illegal
Broadband·November 12, 2026

New York state says T-Mobile broke the law by placing a 50GB data cap on a home internet plan aimed at low-income customers. The state's requirement for home internet is a minimum speed of 25Mbps. Once a household passes the 50GB limit, the plan drops to about 600Kbps, a small fraction of that floor.
The gap is the core of the complaint. At 600Kbps, a household can handle email and basic text browsing, but video calls, streaming, large downloads and many school or telehealth services become hard or impossible to use. Low-income households often rely on exactly these services, and a cap like this tends to hit the heaviest users at the moment they need the connection most.
The argument is that a cheaper plan does not get a pass on the speed standard. Programs that make home internet affordable exist so that people who could not otherwise get online can stay connected. New York's position, as reported, is that a plan that reduces service to a crawl once a monthly allotment runs out does not meet the minimum the law sets, regardless of its price.
The available details are limited. The reporting does not spell out what penalties the state is seeking, and it does not include a response from T-Mobile. Those points will matter as the dispute develops, and they are worth checking against the state's official statements.
Reporting based on an external source.