Race Realism Doesn't Hold Up Under Modern Genetics
Science·November 22, 2026

For decades, a fringe strand of thinking has argued that genes explain average differences in intelligence between racial groups. Its supporters often wrap the claim in the vocabulary of modern biology, citing DNA studies and population data as proof. A closer look at what genetics actually shows tells a different story, and it undercuts the central premise.
The first problem is the idea that race is a clean biological boundary. Human populations vary gradually across geography, and the genetic differences between any two groups are small compared with the variation found inside each of them. Most of the genetic diversity in our species exists within continental populations rather than between them. That is why geneticists generally regard race as a weak tool for predicting an individual's traits, even though ancestry can be useful for describing patterns across large groups.
The second problem is the evidence offered for innate differences. Researchers can now compute polygenic scores that estimate a person's genetic predisposition for traits such as educational attainment or performance on cognitive tests. These scores explain only a modest share of the variation between individuals, and they lose accuracy when applied to people whose ancestry differs from the mostly European samples used to build them. Even where they predict well within a population, that predictive power does not establish why averages differ between groups. Environmental factors such as schooling, nutrition, health and access to testing are known to shape test scores strongly.
In short, the genetic evidence does not show that intelligence is set by race, and the arguments that claim otherwise tend to rest on assumptions the data cannot support. The more defensible conclusion, according to researchers who study human variation, is that genes influence many traits through countless small effects, and that differences in group averages reflect a mix of history, environment and opportunity rather than a fixed biological ranking.
Reporting based on an external source.