Sciencepulse

Why New Year's Resolutions Fail, and the Science That Can Help Them Stick

Behavioral Science·November 22, 2026

Every January, gym check-ins climb and grocery carts fill with kale. By February, many of those promises have quietly lapsed. Behavioral economist Katy Milkman, who studies why people do or don't follow through on what they intend, told Scientific American's Science Quickly podcast that the pattern is not a personal failing. It is a predictable response to how people organize time, and it can be turned to someone's advantage.

Milkman's central idea is what researchers call the "fresh start effect." Milestones such as a new year, a birthday, the first day of a month or even a Monday seem to create a mental break between a past self and a future one. That break makes it easier to picture a different version of yourself and to shrug off the slip-ups of the old one. Research on this effect, including work Milkman has co-authored, has found that interest in goals such as exercise and dieting tends to rise at these moments.

The catch is that a fresh start gets people moving but does not keep them moving. Milkman argues that lasting change depends on habits, and habits depend on design. Rather than relying on daily willpower, people do better when the desired behavior is easier to do, tied to a cue already present in their routine, and repeated until it stops requiring a decision at all.

Several of her practical suggestions follow that logic. One is temptation bundling, which pairs an activity you should do with one you enjoy, such as listening to a favorite audiobook only while on the treadmill. Another is shrinking the first step so small that skipping it feels silly. A third is planning in advance with specific if-then statements, like deciding that after dinner you will walk around the block. That removes the moment of debate, when motivation is lowest and excuses are easiest to find.

Perhaps the most important point is also the least glamorous. Milkman stresses that people need to enjoy the process, not just the result. A resolution built entirely around a distant payoff, such as a number on the scale, asks you to endure discomfort for months with little to show for it. A routine that includes some pleasure in the daily doing is far more likely to survive a rough week or a missed session.

For anyone drafting resolutions, the takeaway is practical. Pick one behavior, attach it to something you already do, make it enjoyable, and plan for the stumble before it happens. Expect to miss a day and decide now what you will do next. Milkman lays out these ideas in more depth in her 2021 book How to Change: The Science of Getting from Where You Are to Where You Want to Be, published by Portfolio, and she also hosts the Choiceology podcast.