Why Spotting a Liar Is Harder Than The Traitors Makes It Look
Science·November 16, 2026
The reality series The Traitors runs on a simple question: which of the players is secretly working against everyone else? That makes it a useful stage for one of psychology's stubborn findings, which is that people are surprisingly bad at telling when someone is lying. In a new episode of Science Quickly, host Kendra Pierre-Louis and Scientific American reporter Jackie Flynn Mogensen use the show as a way into the research on deception.
The core finding is an uncomfortable one. Across many studies, people tend to perform only slightly better than chance when judging whether a speaker is being truthful. Plenty of us still rely on supposed giveaways such as averted eyes, fidgeting, or a nervous swallow. The research suggests those cues are weak and often misleading. Honest people can display them, and practiced liars can learn to suppress them.
That gap matters for the show's contestants. Behavioral science points to approaches that tend to outperform gut instinct, such as tracking whether a player's account stays consistent over time and paying attention to the details a liar has to keep straight. The discussion makes clear, though, that players do not always put these tools to use. Under the social pressure of a game, it is easy to fall back on instinct and personal impressions.
The lesson reaches well beyond a reality competition. Diary studies suggest that lying is a routine part of everyday life for most people, so the limits of lie detection touch job interviews, personal relationships and the way people judge what they read and hear. Scientific American has also published related reading, including a piece on how to win The Traitors according to science and another on how often people lie in a single day, for listeners who want to dig further.