The Human Chin Might Be an Evolutionary Accident
Science·November 14, 2026
Humans are the only living species with a chin, a feature so familiar that most people never give it a second thought. Evolutionary biologists and paleoanthropologists have found it much harder to explain. Various functions have been proposed over the years, but none has become an accepted answer. A recent episode of Science Quickly takes up the puzzle, with host Kendra Pierre-Louis speaking to paleoanthropologist Lauren Schroeder, a co-author of a study that approaches the question from an unusual direction.
That study, written by Noreen von Cramon-Taubadel and colleagues and published in PLOS One in January 2026, asks whether the chin is a spandrel. The term comes from architecture and was popularized in a 1979 essay by Stephen Jay Gould and Richard Lewontin. It describes a feature that appears as a side effect of other changes rather than because natural selection shaped it directly. The classic example is the triangular gap above the arches of a building, which exists because of how the arches meet, not because anyone planned a decorative space there. To test whether the chin fits that pattern, the researchers compared craniomandibular form, the combined shape of the skull and lower jaw, across apes.
The idea reflects a broader point the episode keeps returning to: evolution does not always build traits through tidy, purpose-driven steps. Changes in one part of the body can ripple into others, and some of the resulting features may persist without serving a function of their own. Taking that possibility seriously changes the question. Researchers have to ask not only what a chin does, but whether it was ever the direct target of selection at all.
Readers who want the details of the comparison and the study's conclusions can find them in the episode and the paper itself. The conversation is a useful starting point for anyone who has wondered why the human face carries a feature no other living ape shares.